• 927

威士忌高校

李兄 別想太多~ 這家酒廠第一批出來的1972單桶 大家也都說很好

但是小弟就是不愛此家酒廠的調調~ 一之都沒買(尤其是再參加過品酒會都喝過的情況之下)

小弟當時認為1992那隻最划算超值(不過也都買不到)

所以就都放棄~ 那麼多桶大家都PK過 答案都在各自心中

自己最不喜歡的酒 就算得金牌又怎樣??往好處想就是不用多花錢追~

再來就是別人越不愛的你越愛??? 那爽翻了 因為你不用花到太多的錢就可以買到你的最愛

酒還是要喝過在去下評論 最好是3.5好友一起討論 畢竟我愛甜你愛鹹之間各有喜好落差....

青菜羅蔔各有喜好~ 自己喝過才知道~~~ 這就是威士忌迷人的地方~

所以李兄的個性哪有可能故意說700桶不好然後自己屯貨呢@@?

700桶...我當時品酒會也喝過...的確不突出
p9上有人說要醒酒1-2各禮拜...也是有可能
我之前寫的品酒文格蘭卡登10年剛開平也覺得soso..酒精嗆..香草..奶油..甜味..均偏淡...
開平後每天喝一些到了依各多禮拜後酒精嗆味..不見了...香草..奶油..甜味...變的濃郁..有點像香草冰淇淋..差粉多
我想威士忌各自有各自的開瓶....最佳品飲期......真是猜不透你啊..威士忌...

龜山島主 wrote:
700桶...我當時...(恕刪)


威士忌開瓶後確實味道的濃淡,甚至口感多少都會有些改變,有點變好,有點變差....
不過,小弟的觀念,若是基本款的酒,開瓶後可以變得更好,那麼就是一瓶好酒,
但以格蘭多納700桶的價位,還要開瓶等許久才會變得愈來愈好,縱使變得再怎麼好,
小弟都認為是不成功的酒....消費者花了那麼多錢,還要跟這支酒從拉拉小手開始培養感情...
等了老半年才能....,搞得好像是消費者自己的釀酒一樣,那不如拿這些錢去買幾支已經<煮燒燒>的好酒,
當下就能享受!

louislitw wrote:
這真的是跌破我的眼鏡...(恕刪)


李大 別想太多了關於這些流言蜚語的 這是個人的好惡問題 更何況能坦言自己的判斷 而不人言亦言 又能有多少?

ahong_y2k wrote:
李大 別想太多了關於...(恕刪)

被一瓶酒給推上火線,想想也有點好笑.
不介意啦,如果連這點小事都要介意,那豈不自尋煩惱.我的EQ被股市訓練得還算高,不會為這個傷神啦.
看來是非只為多開口,這句話還真有點道理.

louislitw wrote:
被一瓶酒給推上火線,...(恕刪)


大家等待的MMA終於出來了,有空去看看。
原文出處在這理

ULTRA PREMIUM CATEGORY

Non-Plus-Ultra Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Overall top scoring 'ultra premium' whisky out of all Malt Maniacs Awards entries)
Glendronach 38yo 1972/2010 (49.5%, OB, Sherry C#700, Taiwan)

Best Natural Cask Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Best whisky matured exclusively in 'untreated', regular cask(s)
Caperdonich 37yo 1972/2010 (53.4%, Duncan Taylor Rare Auld, C#7420)

Best Sherry Cask Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Best whisky matured exclusively in sherry cask(s)
Macallan 1970/2010 (46%, Gordon & MacPhail for LMdW, Sherry C#10031)

Best Cask Innovation Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Best whisky matured or finished in 'special' or unusual cask(s)
Dalmore 26yo 1981 Amoroso Sherry finish (42%, OB, 484 Bts.)

Best Peated Malt Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Best whisky distilled from - relatively - peated malt)
Port Ellen 'Pe2' (59.5%, Speciality Drinks Ltd., Bottled +/- 2010)

Thumbs Up Award 2010 (Ultra Premium)
(Most exciting new release in this price category)
Glenfarclas 40yo (46%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)


PREMIUM CATEGORY

Non-Plus-Ultra Award 2010 (Premium)
(Overall top scoring 'premium' whisky out of all Malt Maniacs Awards entries)
Kawasaki 1982/2009 'Ichiro's Choice' (65.4%, OB, LMdW, 668 Bts.)

Best Natural Cask Award 2010 (Premium)
(Best whisky matured exclusively in 'untreated', regular cask(s)
Clynelish 27yo 1982/2010 (59,8% The Nectar Daily Dram)

Best Sherry Cask Award 2010 (Premium)
(Best whisky matured exclusively in sherry cask(s)
Kavalan 'Solist' (58.2%, OB, Sherry C#S060703018, 569 Bts.)

Best Cask Innovation Award 2010 (Premium)
(Best whisky matured or finished in 'special' or unusual cask(s)
Ballechin '#5 Marsala Cask Matured' (46%, OB, Bottled 2010, Peated)

Best Peated Malt Award 2010 (Premium)
(Best whisky distilled from - relatively - peated malt)
Octomore 5yo 'Orpheus Edition 02.2' (61%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Thumbs Up Award 2010 (Premium)
(Most exciting new release in this price category)
Highland Park 12yo 'Saint Magnus' (55%, OB, +/- 2010, 11994 Bts.)


DAILY DRAMS CATEGORY

Non-Plus-Ultra Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Top scoring, affordable and widely available whisky in this category)
Lagavulin 16yo (43%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Best Natural Cask Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Best affordable and widely available whisky matured exclusively in regular cask(s)
Talisker 10yo (45.8%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Best Sherry Cask Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Best affordable and widely available whisky matured exclusively in sherry cask(s)
Aberlour 'A'bunadh' Batch #30 (59.8%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Best Cask Innovation Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Best affordable and widely available whisky matured or finished in 'special' or unusual cask(s)
Kavalan 'Concertmaster' Port Cask Finish (40%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Best Peated Malt Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Best affordable and widely available whisky distilled from - relatively - peated malt)
Longrow 'CV' (46%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)

Thumbs Up Award 2010 (Daily Drams)
(Most exciting affordable and widely available new release in this category)
Bunnahabhain 12yo (46.3%, OB, Bottled +/- 2010)


SPECIAL CATEGORY

Old World Whisky Distillery Award 2010
(A special award we invented to recognise Karuizawa's impressive performance this year)
Karuizawa Distillery, Japan


Young World Whisky Distillery Award 2010
(A special award we invented to recognise Amrut's impressive performance this year)
Amrut Distillery, India


Pressure Cooker Award 2010
(A special award we invented to recognise incredible maturity and complexity ay a young age)
Ledaig 2005/2010 (62.7%, Berry Brothers, C#900008, Germany)


Pressure Cooker Award 2010
(A special award we invented to recognise incredible maturity and complexity ay a young age)
Bunnahabhain 8yo 2001/2010 (54%, TWA LL, Oloroso, 180 Bts.)
第一次在這發言....

李大~~加油!這東西本來就各有所好,別人怎麼講隨他吧! 加油~

kuo0906 wrote:
第一次在這發言......(恕刪)

thank you.

MMA其實像是威士忌的區運,部分廠商參賽.公正性頗受肯定.
有很多蒸餾廠不參加(不寄酒過去比).通常裝瓶廠跟酒商比較熱衷.法國的LMdW就是酒商,榜單裡LMdW就包辦許多獎項(比例很高).
日本的蒸餾廠似乎都不參加(得獎的酒款都不是酒廠自己送去比的).
反正參考參考就好,很有參考價值,但也不是絕對.
挖賽~
小弟終於爬完這583層了...
眼睛都快瞎了

福利社去過一次 老闆娘果然豪邁的給酒喝!!
不過騎肉包鐵的去 不敢喝太多...
入門款買一買趕快烙跑~ 第一次酒駕 @@

印象最深的是試喝聖佛力裝瓶的HP 真的比OB強的多了~
終於懂了大家講的 水水感~ 哞迷~
原來差醬多... 繼續潛水學習~ ^^"

  • 927
禁止酒駕 飲酒過量 有害健康
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
請輸入您要前往的頁數(1 ~ 927)
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?