Android Australia 對htc one, lumia 920及808 pureview低光原拍照比較

沒時間翻譯所以請自己看一下原文, 整體表現認為htc one表現不錯


第一組對照

htc one

lumia 920

808 pureview

原作者對第一組的評論:
"The HTC One acquits itself pretty well here; there’s some mottling in the sky in the top-right corner, but it’s well-focused and there is detail visible in the buildings. The low resolution means there’s not much point zooming in to see high detail, but overall the shot communicates the scene well.

The Lumia 920 seemed to have misfocused, something that wasn’t immediately obvious with a cursory glance at the screen (unfortunately only noticed after leaving the venue), so I wouldn’t judge the sharpness of the 920 with the photo shown (likely user error). The sky is a little lighter on the 920 than the other two, and there is a bit of blotchiness in the sky colour, but most of all the 920 seems to produce a brighter picture than the One or the 808.

The 808 PureView does well; there’s more detail than the One simply because there’s more megapixels of data to work with, and the noise isn’t as bad as a very dense 41MP image sensor might suggest. The obvious difference is file size; the 808 PureView’s shot is a 10MB JPEG file, whereas the One’s JPEG is 837 kB – less than a tenth of the size."

第二組比較:

htc one

lumia 920

808 pureview

原作者對第二組的評論:
"Here, the 808 doesn’t do so well – an f/2.4 lens, compared to the f/2.0 lenses in the One and the 920, meant it struggled to capture enough light for the photo, and the shakiness due to the slow shutter speed really shows.

The Lumia 920 fares much better than the 808 – with its optical image stabilisation, it comes away with the brightest, clearest image of the three. It’s not quite perfect focus, but not bad in the near-zero light.

The One does an middling job here – understand that this is a pretty extreme situation for a phone camera, and even my main camera (a Fujifilm X100) struggles to acquire focus and expose correctly in this light. The most severe issue here is horizontal banding across the image, something that’s quite difficult to improve in editor.

Overall, a reasonably good effort from the One, but not an overall winner – though I’d say it’s at least in the same playing field as the Lumia 920 and the 808 PureView, which is high praise and definitely puts it above the other Android phones on the market today. I’m not ready to call any measure of superiority based on two unscientific tests (especially given the lack of control over the environment), so I leave you, the reader, to make your own judgment.

Once we have our hands on a review sample and can truly put the One’s camera to its paces in more controlled environments, we’ll be exploring what it’s really capable of!"




原網址在這:
http://www.androidaustralia.com.au/2013/02/manufacturers/htc-manufacturers/quick-look-how-good-is-the-htc-ones-camera/


2013-02-24 12:14 發佈
簡單來說原作者認為ONE 平均表現不錯
但是對上這兩支各有輸贏
夜拍低光源表現920還是最優
作者覺得808的照片佔的容量太大


不過蠻好奇808夜拍表現真的是這種程度嗎??

作者總結還是叫讀者自行評斷
評論僅供參考
作者的評語反而是是Lumia 920略勝, 被某些人捧上天的808
因為沒OIS, f/2.4略小的光圏
所以真正的低光源拍攝根本什麼都拍不到

樓主下的結論完完全全和作者下的結論不同
應該是太偏心Nokia了, 十分可笑

ValkyrieVF25 wrote:
樓主下的結論完完全全和作者下的結論不同
應該是太偏心Nokia了, 十分可笑



我沒有偏袒Nokia喔
我覺得htc one整體的表現是不錯的
各有輸贏

內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?