[分享] Qnap網站伺服器及Synology網頁服務web server的比較 (內容更新)

XD9527
個人積分：20分
文章編號：53574401

20分

樓主

2014-12-12 16:24

想請教一下有同時使用過Qnap及Synology來架網站的人
兩家的網站伺服器的功能、穩定度、效能、最大連線數、php版本...等
有沒有前輩可以分享一下心得及比較呢？

以下隨便列個比較表拋磚引玉一下~
資料若有誤的話請告知一下我再修改
希望有人可以補充更多資料以作參考比較

	Synology網頁服務	Qnap網站伺服器
自訂http port	可	可
自訂sql port	好像不可	可
https/SSL	可	可
SQL/DB	mariaDB	mysql
phpmyadmin	有	有
webalizer	有	有
修改php.ini	較麻煩	簡單
虛擬主機	30個站台	32個站台
Apache版本	2.2.27 (DS412+/DSM5.1)	2.2.14 (TS-251/QTS4.1)
MySQL版本	5.5.39 (DS412+/DSM5.1)	5.1.36 (TS-251/QTS4.1)
php版本	5.5.16 (DS412+/DSM5.1)	5.3.28 (TS-251/QTS4.1)
安全性	Synology	Qnap
FireWall防火牆	有	有
自訂ip範圍遮罩	有	有
快選國家ip網段	有	無?
自動封鎖功能	簡略	詳細
DDOS防護	有	無?
自訂ip filter	有	簡略

****** 2014/12/12 加入LAMP版本比較******
****** 2014/12/13 加入安全性資訊 ******

參考資料：
https://www.synology.com/zh-tw/knowledgebase/faq/310
https://amigotechnotes.wordpress.com/

2014-12-12 16:24 發佈

文章關鍵字 QNAP Synology 網站伺服器 Web Server 網頁服務內容

kahnmao

kahnmao
個人積分：6254分
文章編號：53579755

6254分

2樓

2014-12-12 23:27

XD9527 wrote:
想請教一下有同時使用...(恕刪)

看來也是用nas偷懶架站的同好 XD

我有開始打算組台itx裝ubuntu架了

Qnap不知道何時可以修好問題

Qnap 269L 3G ram 靜態網站測試過四個小時瀏覽次數超過3萬人都還可以網路速度不夠會讀取較慢

沒注意最大連線人數過

看httpd設定是1000

貓老闆

XD9527

XD9527
個人積分：20分
文章編號：53580217

20分

樓主

2014-12-13 0:07

kahnmao wrote:
看來也是用nas偷懶...(恕刪)

沒錯XDDD

今年起各家NAS的CPU又提升到另一等級，
(例如synology的新CPU 四核INTEL Atom C2538 算是Server級的架構)

如果系統軟體可以針對web服務再更優化的話，
還是值得期待的～

小弟當然也有考慮自架，之前還想用Intel的NUC來架站XD
系統也想用ubuntu或直接裝centos來慢慢調教，
只是真的很懶，自架建製及維護起來太傷神了...XDDD

XD9527

XD9527
個人積分：20分
文章編號：53587771

20分

樓主

2014-12-13 18:29

****** 2014/12/12 加入LAMP版本比較******
****** 2014/12/13 加入安全性資訊 ******

希望大家也幫忙補充一下跟架站相關的資料喔~
謝謝~

kahnmao

kahnmao
個人積分：6254分
文章編號：53588037

6254分

5樓

2014-12-13 19:03

XD9527 wrote:
****** 201...(恕刪)

今天跟站上的網友測過DS412+

壓力測試後主機仍存活

貓老闆

a19560714

a19560714
個人積分：226分
文章編號：53592141

226分

6樓

2014-12-14 1:42

Synology 的自動封鎖雖然簡略，但卻是非常有效，提供一小段的紀錄給您參考
查閱連線紀錄，好像就是有人在『猜密碼』，有些則是只有連線沒有輸入使用者，一樣在設定的次數連線失敗就擋下來。相當不錯。
至於 mail server，也是一天擋下近5000個連線，廣告信大量減少中。

Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:06:59,SYSTEM,Host [185.14.135.201] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:06:24,SYSTEM,Host [180.211.191.122] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:06:22,SYSTEM,Host [190.38.187.7] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:06:07,SYSTEM,Host [190.74.67.105] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:05:36,SYSTEM,Host [181.185.112.193] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:05:22,SYSTEM,Host [176.223.4.7] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:05:01,SYSTEM,Host [197.8.204.126] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:04:04,SYSTEM,Host [190.37.94.69] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:03:32,SYSTEM,Host [79.114.26.68] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:02:48,SYSTEM,Host [186.14.11.144] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 06:01:37,SYSTEM,Host [199.68.107.233] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:58:59,SYSTEM,Host [220.141.120.8] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:57:57,SYSTEM,Host [61.223.42.120] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:57:05,SYSTEM,Host [95.160.20.105] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:56:44,SYSTEM,Host [5.14.121.239] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:56:35,SYSTEM,Host [186.92.250.6] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:54:36,SYSTEM,Host [217.199.142.235] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:53:54,SYSTEM,Host [103.2.135.207] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:53:22,SYSTEM,Host [186.91.222.125] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:53:21,SYSTEM,Host [197.129.150.62] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:52:02,SYSTEM,Host [178.77.185.51] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:51:54,SYSTEM,Host [46.102.51.189] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:51:39,SYSTEM,Host [79.116.92.252] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:51:20,SYSTEM,Host [80.252.248.126] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:51:16,SYSTEM,Host [193.34.109.170] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:50:36,SYSTEM,Host [178.245.182.76] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:50:27,SYSTEM,Host [124.125.19.131] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:50:08,SYSTEM,Host [79.117.199.46] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:49:32,SYSTEM,Host [110.143.72.198] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:49:29,SYSTEM,Host [103.242.197.163] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:48:53,SYSTEM,Host [79.113.120.23] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:48:51,SYSTEM,Host [37.57.157.244] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:48:21,SYSTEM,Host [197.130.187.18] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:48:17,SYSTEM,Host [80.51.138.47] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:48:04,SYSTEM,Host [37.221.172.78] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:47:36,SYSTEM,Host [185.14.135.34] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:47:21,SYSTEM,Host [86.122.100.123] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:45:36,SYSTEM,Host [93.114.221.155] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:45:35,SYSTEM,Host [83.23.68.29] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:44:37,SYSTEM,Host [197.129.144.203] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:44:24,SYSTEM,Host [200.8.25.112] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:44:16,SYSTEM,Host [190.199.255.199] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:44:14,SYSTEM,Host [41.92.23.121] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:58,SYSTEM,Host [79.116.194.203] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:55,SYSTEM,Host [14.97.97.146] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:51,SYSTEM,Host [188.173.214.117] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:49,SYSTEM,Host [83.9.164.32] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:35,SYSTEM,Host [5.233.136.224] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:23,SYSTEM,Host [190.75.140.221] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:08,SYSTEM,Host [111.253.206.183] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:08,SYSTEM,Host [197.230.150.142] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:43:00,SYSTEM,Host [197.6.239.143] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:42:53,SYSTEM,Host [190.198.179.154] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:42:39,SYSTEM,Host [89.178.71.252] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:42:23,SYSTEM,Host [5.15.172.236] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:41:59,SYSTEM,Host [41.100.154.111] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:41:22,SYSTEM,Host [117.200.171.57] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:40:26,SYSTEM,Host [186.94.183.36] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:40:26,SYSTEM,Host [5.178.245.220] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:40:07,SYSTEM,Host [111.255.84.83] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:39:45,SYSTEM,Host [223.29.200.86] was blocked via [Mail Server].
Warning,系統,2014/12/13 05:39:33,SYSTEM,Host [190.74.194.91] was blocked via [Mail Server].

kahnmao

kahnmao
個人積分：6254分
文章編號：53595062

6254分

7樓

2014-12-14 12:47

準備出售269L轉群輝415+試試了

昨天網友的機器效能實在有點讓我驚恐...

WORDPRESS速度快上很多

貓老闆

kahnmao

kahnmao
個人積分：6254分
文章編號：53596412

6254分

8樓

2014-12-14 15:23

kahnmao wrote:
準備出售269L轉 ...(恕刪)

奢侈 DS415+改8G WITH 120G SSD*2 2TB*2 配置測試中

貓老闆