Mobile01沒有物理板, 只好po在這.
有網友看過Stephen Hawking的紀錄片"Curiosity: Did God Create the Universe?"嗎?
Dr. Hawking 推論:
1. Inside the black hole, time stops due to the Gravitational time dilation.
2. The very beginning of the universe is also a black hole. Just infinitely dense.
3. There is no time at that very beginning, so God has no time to create the universe.
4. So God didn't create the universe.
然而, 所謂的 "no time" 應該是相對於black hole外的observer. 相對於outsider, insider的時間跑得很慢, 慢到看似停止. 但 Black hole 裡面時間依舊前進. 並沒有停止.
我的問題是, Dr. Hawking 所說的no time, time stops, 所指為何? 難道沒有和相對論牴觸嗎?
arcangel wrote:
沒有抵觸。有抵觸的話...(恕刪)
我認為與相對論有牴觸, 所以我跳出來了.
理論物理學家 Michio Kaku 也認為 Dr. Hawking 的結論下得太快了.
國外的論壇吵成一團, 我很好奇台灣物理同好的看法, 故在此提問,...
期望大家能根據事實做推論
ckkc wrote:
根據大師的說法, 一...(恕刪)
根據NASA's image of the universe
http://imagine.gsfc.nasa.gov/docs/ask_astro/answers/011024a.html
時間在黑洞內會繼續前進
掉到黑洞裡的人如果可以看到黑洞外的時間
則會發現外面的時間跑得比裡面快
紀錄片38分59秒說
"here too, time must come to a stop. You can't get to a time before the big bang because there was no before the big bang, ... there is no cause because there is no time for a cause to exist. For me it means there is no possibility of a creator. Because there is no time for a creator to exist. ... time didn't exist before the big bang, ... so there is no time for creator to make the universe,... there is no God."
NO TIME 是大師推論的關鍵. 然而根據相對論, 時間只是相對於外面變慢, 並沒有停掉. 那哪來的NO TIME呢?
內文搜尋
從 APP 打開
X