• 29

小孩從母姓很困難嗎?這段婚姻還持續得下去? (文長)

當初找個同姓的不就好了
不管從父 或是從母
都沒有關係
什麼問題都沒有
coon0909 wrote:
心裡很掙札到底要不要...(恕刪)


我覺得,小孩從母姓或從父姓的重要性,

有比給小孩一個完整的家,還來的重要嗎??

若真的離婚,將來小孩問起離婚的原因,

樓主好意思說出口嗎??

不過妳老公也蠻沒擔當的,自己答應的事,婚後卻找藉口耍賴!!

我身旁也有複姓跟從母姓的朋友,他們都還是長子!!

也沒看過他們覺得困擾過,或被取笑過!!

反而從母姓的那位朋友,因此而繼承了一大片土地!!

離婚很容易,也沒什麼特別的!

但小孩是無辜的!!好嗎??




coon0909 wrote:
心裡很掙札到底要不要...(恕刪)

應該說
從母姓難嗎?
換句話,
不從母姓難嗎?

你都可以堅持要翻臉不爽了
想想
男生何嘗不是!

或許男生有很多不可喻的事情先不談,那你自己呢?堅持從母姓

只為了『神主牌』,掛點後有人送終嗎?鄉下是這樣啦。
我是蓮霧王 ~路過蓮霧園
我覺得重點還是不在你老公出爾反爾
如果我是妳的話,我也不會把這樣的話當真
俗有云:人不為已,天誅地滅;事情碰到了(第一胎生女兒了),才會知道對第二胎的想法

畢竟男方已經很"大方"了,願意分一個小孩從女方姓了,這已經很足夠了
抗議適可而止,誰知道你有沒有小男孩的緣,就先為第二胎爭成一團
說不定還一直生女兒哩~ (當然希望你能連二胎都是男孩)

你媽媽的建議很好!
還有女人不要太強勢
不然比較生不到小男孩,去做精蟲分離吧

不然一連生三個女生(有可能)
加上此次的芥蒂,以後還真會吵的沒完沒了
男方說不定還會藉口去外面生,婆婆也不會給你好臉色
abc6469 wrote:
最佳解決方法就是多生...(恕刪)

no...
我覺得最佳的解決辦法就是離婚,再找一個跟自己同姓的嫁,這樣不管跟誰姓都一樣...
反正男方的家人看女方也很不順眼...
我想我沒有重男輕女得理由!

因為現在是少子化!能有多少小孩 已經是很幸福!

我認為妳先生很愛你 所以會答應你這些條件!

但是 你又何必這麼在乎妳父母!因為你太孝順了!

有時候 第三者 會把自己得婚姻搞砸 這第三者來自各自得家人!

我先生是笑子!笑到不行得笑子 我返對從母性得原因

是以後得基因會更為複雜 如果沒有祖孫帶著跑

往後基因有問題時 該如何解決?

中國人得姓氏 的確有他得道理~~

以前我樓下太太也是如此要求 結果 半個子都沒有

建議你 上面得事 講講聽聽 就好 你還要跟你老公相處一輩子

你何不等小孩大了 再跟他們討論

現在就由你來決定 不是很不公平 對小孩不公平

為一個字 拆散家庭???
對小孩 何其忍心??






就算讓小孩從了母姓或是維持父姓又如何?

民法才剛改說你想的話連姓都可以換掉

說不定從了母姓,小孩長大又跑去換自己喜歡的姓呀....
I think you guys are ridiculous, especially your parents. I agree with your husband in the sense that 'name' is just something you use to call things. No matter what, they are still your children.

Of course he shouldn't have agreed with you first and then changed his mind, that'll make you feel cheated.

Two advices I give you:

1) You are already a married person. A married person should have a mature mind and indepenedent thoughts. Just because your parents want to have someone with your last name, is it the way it must be? To your husband, of course he doesn't want ppl to make fun of him that the kids has a different last name as he does, but is this so important to getting divorced over? And to you, is it so important to please your parents that you'll destroy your own family and let your kids become parentless? THINK about it. You are not only your parents' "good daughter" anymore. You are at the same time, your husband's wife, and children's mother.

2) Don't ever say divorce. it's an irresponsible and childish thing to have babies and divorce. Think about the effects it will have on your children FOR THEIR WHOLE LIFE wondering why they can't have a NORMAL family, simply because you want to make your parents happy and have 1 kid with their last name. You call your husband a liar for not following through on his promise, but divorcing makes you ditch the oath you took when you two get married that you'll be together for life and "for better or worse."

Is it worth it? To an outsider, you are taking your marriage as a childish game.
好多大大回喔~但有沒有是自身的經驗後給的建議呢?

我是從母姓的,年紀也不小了,在過去沒有法律允許從母姓的條件下,我經常被問到"為什麼你性張,你弟姓林"?爸爸不是入贅,只因為媽媽家裡沒有男孩,在過去農業社會,總是希望有個男孩來"傳宗接代"~

我從母姓,對小時候的我,或許有些影響,但那也僅是每次總要多做說明!
不過,説清楚點,我是從母從父姓,所以是"複姓",就像是"郭李建夫"一樣,不過我是3個字,或許可以給樓主參考~

我跟爸爸、媽媽的感情很好~我超愛他們的,不會因為"姓"的關係,影響了我們的情感!我也結婚了,就之前的原因,我的想還當然也是跟著我姓張,也是沒問題!!
說那嚜多,無疑是希望樓主,情緒的問題先放下,這些都不是大不了事,重點是,你對小孩的解釋跟教育,不要傷了和氣,意氣用事的離了婚~

順便說~我還生了3個女兒呢?就原來媽媽的目的,看樣子是失敗了....
又怎樣~我還跟爸媽一起住耶~,家裡幸福的很,就當我在炫耀好了!!
順便跟我的老婆說聲謝謝,這年頭,要跟公婆一起住的不多了!!
樓主請寬心,放下!你會得到更多~祝福你囉~
無意冒犯~我也是複姓~不過我很幸福喔~也祝福你!!
  • 29
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
請輸入您要前往的頁數(1 ~ 29)
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?