• 4

FE24240是不是一隻物有所值的旅遊鏡 part II PK FE2470

疑問:FE24240是不是一隻物有所值的旅遊鏡?是否打趴FE2470? 可否取而代之?

拍攝條件:上腳架, 用快門線, 關防手震 ISO100, +0.7EV, 中央對焦
為了避免腳架晃動影響畫質, 小弟這次腳架是用Kingjue勁捷 C-K407 碳纖維腳架, 雲台則是用沙雀 SACHTLER FSB-8T 油壓雲台, 以減少腳架雲台造成的影響

原始圖檔
FE2424024mmF3.5 by ldg111, on Flickr


先看24端
排列方式FE24240放在上面, FE2470在下面

在中間裁切一張1024*768區塊, 及左邊裁切1024*768區塊, 每張照片下面皆有標出焦段光圈, 將依序由F4 PO 到F22
但 FE24240有一張F3.5單獨列出


FE2424024mmF3.5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE2424024mmF3.5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F4之後才有兩者的比較

FE2424024mmF4_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF4_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF4_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF4_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




F4.5

FE2424024mmF4.5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF4.5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF4.5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF4.5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




F5

FE2424024mmF5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




F5.6

FE2424024mmF5.6_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF5.6_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF5.6_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF5.6_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F6.3


FE2424024mmF6.3_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF6.3_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE2424024mmF6.3_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF6.3_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




F7.1


FE2424024mmF7.1_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF7.1_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF7.1_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF7.1_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F8


FE2424024mmF8_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF8_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF8_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF8_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F9


FE2424024mmF9_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF9_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF9_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF9_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F10


FE2424024mmF10_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF10_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF10_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF10_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F11


FE2424024mmF11_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF11_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF11_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF11_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




F13


FE2424024mmF13_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF13_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF13_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF13_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F14


FE2424024mmF14_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF14_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF14_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF14_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F16


FE2424024mmF16_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF16_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF16_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF16_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F18


FE2424024mmF18_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF18_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF18_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF18_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F20


FE2424024mmF20_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF20_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424024mmF20_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247024mmF20_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F22


FE2424024mmF22_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF22_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE2424024mmF22_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247024mmF22_crL by ldg111, on Flickr




再看70端
F5.6之前只有FE2470


F4
FE247070mmF4_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF4_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F4.5

FE247070mmF4.5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247070mmF4.5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F5


FE247070mmF5_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247070mmF5_crL by ldg111, on Flickr





F5.6之後才有兩者比較



FE2424070mmF5.6_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF5.6_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE2424070mmF5.6_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF5.6_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F6.3


FE2424070mmF6.3_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF6.3_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF6.3_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF6.3_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F7.1


FE2424070mmF7.1_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF7.1_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF7.1_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF7.1_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F8


FE2424070mmF8_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF8_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE2424070mmF8_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF8_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F9


FE2424070mmF9_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247070mmF9_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE2424070mmF9_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF9_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F10


FE2424070mmF10_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF10_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF10_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF10_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F11


FE2424070mmF11_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF11_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF11_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF11_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F13


FE2424070mmF13_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF13_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE247070mmF13_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF13_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F14


FE247070mmF14_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF14_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF14_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF14_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F16


FE2424070mmF16_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247070mmF16_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE247070mmF16_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF16_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F18


FE24724070mmF18_crC by ldg111, on Flickr


FE247070mmF18_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE2424070mmF18_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF18_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


F20


FE2424070mmF20_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF20_crC by ldg111, on Flickr



FE2424070mmF20_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF20_crL by ldg111, on Flickr



F22


FE2424070mmF22_crC by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF22_crC by ldg111, on Flickr




FE247070mmF22_crL by ldg111, on Flickr

FE247070mmF22_crL by ldg111, on Flickr


很驚訝吧! 兩隻鏡頭在廣角及望遠端幾乎不分軒輊, FE2470除了在70端多了F4到F5的光圈外, 幾乎佔不到什麼優勢, 但FE24240在24端也多了F3.5的光圈, 該說FE24240太強, 還是FE2470浪得菜頭虛名, 希望不久的將來, FE2470能有改版的機會, 小弟是覺得這兩隻幾乎戰成了平手, 至於FE24240是不是會打趴FE70200, 敬請期待PART III, 說真的, 小弟是不敢抱持太樂觀態度, 畢竟FE70200是FE鏡中的強鏡。



新增了幾組實拍,每組條件都相同, 第1組光圈F6.3, 第1組光圈F11, 小弟是木眼, 看不出來什麼差別
第一張是F24240, 第二章是F2470




F6.3

FE 24-240mm F6.3-3 by ldg52121, on Flickr


FE 24-70mmF6.3-2 by ldg52121, on Flickr




F11

FE 24-240mm F11-3 by ldg52121, on Flickr


FE 24-70mmF11-2 by ldg52121, on Flickr




F6.3


FE 24-240mm F6.3-1 by ldg52121, on Flickr


FE 24-70mmF6.3-1 by ldg52121, on Flickr

F11

FE 24-240mm F11-1 by ldg52121, on Flickr


FE 24-70mmF11-1 by ldg52121, on Flickr


F6.3


FE 24-240mm F6.3-2 by ldg52121, on Flickr

FE 24-70mmF6.3-3 by ldg52121, on Flickr



F11

FE 24-240mm F11-2 by ldg52121, on Flickr



FE 24-70mmF11-3 by ldg52121, on Flickr






2015-04-10 0:35 發佈
ldg52121 wrote:
兩隻鏡頭在廣角及望遠端幾乎不分軒輊...(恕刪)

頭香...
期待近期有跳水24-70好撿...
喂... 不是啦... 是熱血好文大推...
不愧為3G評測員... 期待Part III...

我覺得24-70不能取代的地方有二...
在眾多24-70裡... 他的星芒算滿極品的...
在眾多24-70裡... 他算滿好便攜的...
至於CP... 蔡司鏡沒有在管的吧...

雖然24-70有許多負面聲音...
但國內外還是看到不少令人印象改觀的毒照...
我自己的使用經驗... 畫質是可以接受的...
只是我還是出掉... 選擇了更為便攜的28-70...
我覺得... 選擇自己能接受... 並能常帶出去的... 就是你的好鏡...
樓主真的好用心,值得表揚,


可是小弟有點困惑,如果測試只是用簡單的黑白色 和 大字體文字,可以看出鏡頭的色彩表現 和 細節表現嗎?


小弟猜想 如果 用有豐富色彩 和 豐富細節 的 東西 做測試 ,會不會更好?


謝謝指教
MING CHAN wrote:
小弟猜想 如果 用有豐富色彩 和 豐富細節 的 東西 做測試 ,會不會更好?...(恕刪)

對啊... 樓主真的很有心... 又樂於分享... 難能可貴...
我覺得樓主並不是要做到100%完美的評測...
而是在他的能力內... 提供了版友一些資訊參考...

樓主的比較方法不盡完美... 但是比較客觀能分別高低...
樓主在測的是...
每個焦段... 每個光圈... 每個位置... 的解析能力...
這是比較客觀的高低...

當然一顆鏡頭的好壞不會只有這些... 而是整個拍出來的畫面... 感覺... 你喜不喜歡...
這包含了色彩... 細節... 過度... 等等... 太多因素了...
但這些因素其實滿主觀的...
有可能A喜歡... B不喜歡...

所以小弟上面才說... 選擇自己能接受... 又樂於帶出門的... 就是你的好鏡... 其他資訊... 當個參考...
說真的... 許多動人的毒照... 都不是用解析最利的鏡頭拍的吧...
ldg52121 wrote:
疑問:FE24240...(恕刪)

ldg大又在害人了

(手機回文)
ldg52121 wrote:
疑問:FE24240...(恕刪)


~~ldg大犧牲睡眠時間在01發文分享,,,,真是辛苦了,,,,還是要來給您按個讚^^V
我不是在星巴克喝咖啡,就是在前往星巴克的路上^^,來一杯.小星星吧^^V

gelinma wrote:
ldg大又在害人了...(恕刪)



辛苦了!

ldg52121 wrote:
疑問:FE24240...(恕刪)

ldg大加油~支持您~呵呵!
phd261106 wrote:
頭香...
期待近期...(恕刪)
我覺得... 選擇自己能接受... 並能常帶出去的... 就是你的好鏡...

夜晚偶見清朗月圓月總會拍幾張
天上的明月 - 清靜農場月圓又大(NEX-5R + SEL55210 )

地上的明鏡 - 月全蝕隔日之月圓月(A7S + FE 70-200G )

硬漢的永遠粉絲
感謝樓主的分享,小弟我也同時擁有SEL24240及SEL2470Z兩支鏡頭,前天也有私底下自行針對兩者的24端及70端的各光圈做簡易的測試,跟樓主測的結果相同,有些光圈甚至SEL24240更勝一籌,在我來看這支是物超所值的鏡頭,也已成為我鏡頭蓋了!
《光的瞬間,影的永恆》 拾影人的浮光掠影 https://www.flickr.com/photos/jerryyangyyx/
  • 4
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?