攜帶型相機的抉擇 Sony T100 vs Canon 850IS, Ricoh R6, Panasonic TZ3

板上各位先進,

小弟最近想要將用了三年的Nikon CP3700換掉,
在Mobile01以及各網站看了些介紹與測試文章,加上自己的需求鎖定了幾台相機

大概需求是
1. 朋友聚會紀錄 (室內為主)
2. 旅遊紀錄 (廣角/高倍光學變焦)
3. 輕便/好攜帶

目前中意的相機有下列四台,預算大概是10000~15000
1. Sony T100
2. Canon 850IS
3. Ricoh R6
4. Panasonic TZ3

SonyT100: 沒有廣角,但有5X光學變焦,若買這台,可能要加上廣角的配件來使用

Canon 850IS: 有28mm廣角,但是光學變焦只有3.8X,如果要拍攝較遠的場景可能就不夠了,例如去看NBA球賽

Ricoh R6: 有28mm廣角,也有7.1X光學變焦,顧慮的部份是成像品質以及閃光燈過曝的問題

Panasonic TZ3: 兼具廣角,10X光學變焦,最大缺點是不夠輕便

不知板上先進比較推薦哪一款呢??
話說小弟女友昨日購入一台T100,可惜還沒有機會將機子拿來把玩一番,
所以才上來請教,還請各位不吝指教,謝謝.

Chris
2007-04-27 6:52 發佈
I am thinking the same thing. i can share some of my experience and thought.

I had a Sony T30, i found the image quality is not so good. When taking interior shot, the noise is very clear. I usually put it on AUTO. for interior normal light, the ISO is around 200 to 320. for some reason, even at ISO 200 to 320, the noise is very obvious. I am thinking to buy T100, but afraid the same thing.

On the test shot made by reviewer, the noise is very little. Very different from my experience.

SD800IS: after seeing the new SD750 and SD1000, the LCD on SD800IS looks very ugly. it has very short battery life. however, i like the color of canon camera.

Ricoh, too big. TZ3, too big. I usually put camera into my pocket.

I am waiting for Canon's new IS camera or see more example of T100.
Antus wrote:
When taking interior shot, the noise is very clear....(恕刪)

室內 t30 的 iso320 照片,不開閃光燈~以縮圖而言其實還 ok 的
做為隨身紀錄的工具而言,算是很稱職

當然希望新機表現能更好
call me 五六么
按照你的三個要求,我相信R6最適合你,我曾經試用過一次,它不但反應快,變焦對焦反應也可以,最主要是它的外觀不錯,由廣角至中段都有,本人推薦你買R6,希望你有所參考。

Antus wrote:
I am thinking the same thing. i can share some of my experience and thought.


I have a T9.

I should say; Sony T series’ image quality is good comparing to similar machines from other manufacturer.

According to DCView, T30’s noise is more than T9’s.
HOWEVER, Canno 850 IS is even worse than T30.

T100’s noise performance should be better than T30.
As a matter of fact, Sony’s ISO performance in Ultra-portable machines is only behind Fujiflim. Nikion and Cannon’s ultra-portable machine is even weaker in this field.

Bear in mind, with the smaller CCD, do not expect too much in terms of noise performance to any of these machine.

You should use the Program / Manual function of these cameras and set ISO at a lower value. For example, instead of ISO 320, 1/30 sec by Auto Mode; you can set ISO at 200, with the help of the Super Steady Shot, grab your machine stable, you should get a better picture.

Check out the ultra-portable camera from different manufacturer, you can see that the Sony T machines are actually doing very well already.

You can rule out Panasonic directly, ISO 200 is bad already, anything higher than that will yield a WaterColor Paint.

R6 has a lot of functions, but believe me, (or believe those professional review online), its high ISO performance is even worse.

Fujiflim Z5fd is another choice, I have played it for a day.
True, it’s high ISO performance may be better than that of Sony.
However, it has its problem also.

It has a limited battery life, and, its Auto mode cannot limit max ISO.
If you use Auto mode, you will find it always push the ISO all the way to 1600, and the results is watercolor paints.

Considering all the points mentioned above, I would highly recommend Sony T100 as your replacement machine.




The New Flying MacBook Pro; Seatbelts sold Separately!
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?