Nikon AF 28-105mm F3.5-4.5D IF 或是 N28-200mm F3.5-5.6 D 這兩支??
會列出的原因是因為拍賣看的到這些老鏡頭.
01的APS-C討論中有
敗入 Nikon 28-105mm 3.3~4.5 marco & 35-70mm 2.8
也可以看看Flicker D700 + 28-105 的照片集,好像拍得還不錯(微距也是).
也有國外網站 Nikonians 的評估報告
==================================
I. PRICE*
* Quoted from B&H in the USA as of November 21, 2005 in US dollars, and without considering rebates
- Lens Price USA USD Imported USD
- 28-105mm f/3.5-4.5D IF AF $325
- 24-85mm f/2.8-4D IF AF $510
- 35-70mm f/2.8D AF $680
The 28-105mm remains the most economical of the three.
II. VERSATILITY (From landscapes to head and shoulders portraits) -
- If you are into portraits, but also want to have the opportunity of making landscapes, again, the 28-105mm seems the clear winner for versatility.
- If the landscapes are the primary concern, then the choice is the 24-85mm, that still allows for good portraits.
- The 35-70mm allows for moderate wide-angle shots to moderate close-up portrait shots.
III. SPEED (For brighter viewfinder view and available light shots)
- The 35-70mm has a constant aperture of 2.8
- Then the 24-85mm with a 2.8, changing to f/4 as it goes into 85mm
- The 28-105mm, at a max aperture of 3.5, is the slowest, hardly any good for ambient light photography, or extreme selective focus, as expected. Obviously not many of its happy users are into that type of photography.
IV. PERFORMANCE (Sharpness -resolution + acutance- and color rendering)
This is what justifies the price differences. The order under Price and Versatility is reversed, as optical performance is highest with the 35-70mm (even when compared with the 28-70mm f/2.8 AF-S which costs more than twice as much as shown here), followed by the 24-85mm and then closely by the 28-105mm.
It is important to note that if apertures are always around or at f/8, users will hardly notice the difference, especially if no huge enlargements are made. It should also be said that the 28-105 nevertheless has remarkable performance, especially if compared with all other zooms in the range not listed here.
V. OTHER FACTORS
If you treat your lenses well, built can be no major problem and it is not a concern at all in any of the lenses compared here.
Of course there are other factors (minor to me) such as front element rotation, etc. and others in the table below. As for macro mode maximum reproduction ratios, the 28-105mm has 1:2, very close to that of the 24-85mm with 1:2; for the 35-70mm it is 1:4; so the three have a quasi-micro capability or macro mode.
- Lens Weight
Size
Filter size
- 28-105mm f/3.5-4.5D IF AF 455g / 16.0oz
73.0 x 81.5mm
62mm
- 24-85mm f/2.8-4D IF AF 545g / 19.2oz
78.5 x 82.5mm
72mm
- 35-70mm f/2.8D AF 665g / 23.5oz
71.5 x 94.5mm
62mm
The 28-105mm lens is the lightest, smallest and with a standard filter size.
......
This lens has a hybrid-type aspherical lens element for minimized distortion and is compact enough to make it a good all-around lens at a reasonable price
點選看作者所示範的銳利度與散景效果
點選看N28-105mm搭配D2X的照片
=======================================================
另外N28-200mm F3.5-5.6 D ,01上只有D80這篇
[PK]被遺忘的全幅旅遊鏡皇.....AI AF ZOOM Nikkor 28-200mm F3.5-5.6D（IF)
看來畫質不輸我的一機一鏡 N18-200mm VR
一樣,這是Nikonians 的N28-200mm G的評論,不過是G鏡...
一起帶的鏡頭就是 A09 和 N50 1.4D
A09 CP 值很高, 又很輕便
有了它暫時不需要鏡皇
N50 1.4 畫質十分優秀
在全幅機上更是美的沒話說
是一定要買的鏡頭
至於 S24-70 2.8 就不用考慮了
因為 24焦段會有很明顯的暗角
而且82mm 濾鏡接環 以及 重量 和價格這幾點都遜於 A09
建議先買 A09 和 N50 1.4D
輕巧的裝備, 優秀的畫質
是很不錯的組合
briankoby wrote:
小弟入手 D700 ...(恕刪)
==================================
哈哈 ~我也知道N50-1.4G這棵真的是很棒呀!
但是再被勸敗,可就真的是一手定焦鏡了.
但是各位大德呀,這樣可以帶小朋友出門嗎??
====================================
2009-11-16 00:31 by hsu4886
如果預算是個問題
A09建議先買
搭D700的CP值絕對破表
不過他會垂頭(雖然有卡榫)
加上他的顏色和24-85比起來
我覺得24-85比較順眼...
====================================
哇!會垂頭!這可犯了我的大忌,這點可是N18-200VR最讓我
受不了的地方,真想把她賣掉了.
Hsu4886大要不要來蓋個24-85 f2.8-4 D 的大樓呢!?
也許我以後也會加入.
這幾天先上網花了幾張小朋友買了一顆品像還不錯的
Nikon AF 28-105mm 的老鏡玩玩,銳利度和對焦速度
都還不錯耶! 晚些再來po些圖.
大小重量都蠻平衡的,適合旅行.
50-105mm時還有1:2的MACRO.很方便!
對焦是在"安全"的"安"字上
這一隻好像當年"動感小帆"大有配合D70拍過很棒的照片.
===================================
Nikkor 28-105mm
是我買D70時候的基本配件.. 也沒有別的了
我在中國旅行及紐西蘭九個月 都是拿著D70+ 28-105mm的相機.. 沒有其他的了
====================================
內文搜尋
從 APP 打開
X