• 4

X230與X220比較心得

上周剛入手X230,使用一周心得如下:

鍵盤手感很好,回饋的聲音小於X220,前三日對排列不是很習慣,常打錯字,現在打字速度已超過舊機。

我X230選IPS面板,相較於X220(同樣是IPS),亮度色域幾乎一樣,猜想是同一塊面板

電源管理比X220好,我這台X230還是三代i7,舊機X220是二代i5,但X230卻讓我覺得風扇比較小聲,熱度跟i5 X220時差不多,同是6 cell電池,X230可使用的電池時間大約多30分鐘。

我自己是很滿意X230,花以前舊機的錢卻可以買到i7的配備,很多人說鍵盤不好打,我想很多人可能只是看看照片,說不定連實機都沒用過,這鍵盤必須花個2-3天適應,如果你是從X4X~這樣一路用上來,可能需要再多幾天,但適應後肯定會愛上新鍵盤的排法。

2012-08-03 1:08 發佈
文章關鍵字 X230 X220
面板我查料號是同一塊沒錯 就是修正色斑後的

風扇真的蠻小聲的 我SATA跟mSATA都裝SSD上去 整機幾乎靜音

不過有一點最不習慣 不是鍵盤 是電源變動時(插電/拔電/睡眠)不會Beep

lenovo forums有員工證明這是被拿掉的功能
Pond Fish wrote:
上周剛入手X230,...(恕刪)

"花以前舊機的錢卻可以買到i7的配備",大大是指這次打折優惠購入的關係嗎?
美國官網目前沒折扣選配最陽春的X230 i7,一直按next到最後好像美金一千上下可入手,當然多半買家會再增加配料進補就貴了.新舊款鍵盤觸感.回饋力道其實差不多,習慣後不會比較難打.為大家詬病嫌棄的多半還是視覺方面吧!市場多數人認為舊款220的排列比較好看,多年來屬於Lenovo特有的就這麼捨棄掉,覺得可惜罷了!我個人也是屬於偏好舊款多一些些,趁近日電腦展再多看看,大家也只能嘗試著去習慣新鍵盤了!
chengyu1226 wrote:
"花以前舊機的錢卻可...(恕刪)


我是趁日前有打折碼請代購買的,入手下來含運費還不到3萬5,算起來非常超值。

筆電這種東西應該跟著新規走,光是處理器跟內顯效能就差別非常多,除非你是抱著收藏心態,
不然實在找不出為何要買舊機的理由。
舊的X220有打算出售嗎?在考慮要不要買
lefou wrote:
舊的X220有打算出...(恕刪)


已經打算讓給同事了

如真的喜歡X220,現在應該價格都滿漂亮的,直接買庫存新機好些吧
不過我個人還是建議買X230, 如果真的在意鍵盤,買個X220的鍵盤換上也是可行的,
等兩年後Lenovo推X240時,想換機時X230還是有市場價值的。
這2個月媒體和一般用戶對新ThinkPad鍵盤的實際反饋評價來看,對新鍵盤本身是非議不大的。大家的意見還是集中在「改」的實施上。

在這裡除了極少數企圖強加個人意願給別人的所謂的“ThinkPad老用戶”之外,實際使用報告看,新鍵盤在手感上還是沒有辜負ThinkPad之名的。

靜等下週一X1c開售~
我之前是用x201 ,以剛入手的x230 來看,打字的手感我是覺得還ok,不會難打,但是就是不習慣,我從T20 x31 x61 x201 到x230 ,突然改變這麼大的的鍵盤排列,就是不習慣,但鍵盤的回饋感,我是覺得ok的啦....

Notebookreview.com 和Notebookcheck.com 的筆電評測向來十分詳實,以下引用兩個網站對於T430& X230 新鍵盤的看法:

Notebookreview.com:
Lenovo ThinkPad T430 Review: The Best Just Got Worse

...
The T430's keyboard is a departure for Lenovo; they switched to the increasingly popular Chiclet style with extra spacing between the keys. This has the most encouraging tactile feedback out of all the variants I've tried. It has a slightly more clicky sound than the traditional ThinkPad keyboards and the key travel isn't as long, though the feedback doesn't suffer as a result, dare I say it feels even more solid. Lenovo is offering a backlit keyboard courtesy of this new design, a first on a 'real' ThinkPad. It still has the Think Light for die-hard fans, though.

So what's the matter with it? Simply put, more than a few ThinkPad owners will say Lenovo botched the keyboard layout. The Home, End, PgUp, PgDn, Insert and Delete keys are all over the place instead of being clustered in a nice organized group at the top right. Also missing is the multi-colored keys such as the purple [Enter]. This bothers me in a way; the ThinkPad keyboard formula was exactly what many business users wanted and now they changed it - what was the reasoning? It doesn't make sense to the end user. I'm all for change but this is a step backwards.
...
What?! A complaint about a ThinkPad keyboard? Lenovo 'upgraded' to a Chiclet-style model; it feels great and as a ThinkPad owner I'm not disappointed but the layout is not the same. The multi-colored keys are also gone. It's still a great keyboard but no longer true to its roots.
...
Cons:Non-standard keyboard layout
...
Quick Take:
The ThinkPad T430 is still "the king of 14-inch business notebooks" but the keyboard might not be changing for the better.



Notebookreview.com:
Lenovo ThinkPad X230 Review: Road Warrior Perfection
...
The keyboard on the ThinkPad X230 is Lenovo's new "Precision Keyboard" with LED backlighting. Although there will certainly be some diehard fans of the traditional Lenovo keyboard, the X230 uses a Chiclet-style key design not unlike what we've seen on most consumer laptops over the last decade. The main key sizes are still 100% of normal but know there is additional space between each key to help prevent typos.  The typing surface has excellent support with barely any flex under heavy pressure. The tactile feel from each key is great with soft clicks emitting very little noise when fully pressed. You can type for hours at a time without much discomfort.
...


Notebookcheck.com
Lenovo ThinkPad X230 2306-2AU Laptop Review
...
After years of having the same keyboard design across their ThinkPad lineup, Lenovo will this year be introducing its new (and mandatory) Precision Keyboard to many of its latest model revisions including those of the popular L, T, X and W series. The keyboards of the ThinkPad X1 or Edge E420s released in mid-2011 can be considered precursors to the new design and may be something that veteran ThinkPad users may not be very fond of at first glance.

The classic beveled keyboard layout typically associated with ThinkPads has been completely dropped in favor of a Chiclet-style build (29.0cm x 11.5cm) that now more closely resembles other keyboards found in other notebooks. The flat, evenly-spaced keys are quite an odd sight to see on an otherwise traditional ThinkPad. According to Lenovo, one of the reasons for the change is that the more modern island design allows for a larger target area per key, which should theoretically lead to fewer errors while typing.

In our opinion, the new setup does indeed feel more streamlined and clean and even less cramped, although fingerprints will build up quickly. Clatter has also been reduced, but we found the keys to be a bit softer (especially the top row F keys) than what veteran ThinkPad users may be used to. Nonetheless, key depth is still adequate and feels deeper than most other Chiclet keyboards even on larger notebooks.

Perhaps the greatest benefit of the chiclet style is that it allows a keyboard backlight. Although only two levels of brightness are user-controllable on the X230, the backlight is nonetheless very bright and will surely be welcomed by ThinkPad fanatics. The trademark ThinkLight feature remains as well, although the notebook does not allow both the backlight and ThinkLight to be active simultaneously
...
But at the end of the day, it’s the changes to the input devices that will have potential buyers raising red flags. ThinkPad veterans will undoubtedly approach the new keyboard with caution while other users fresh to the Thinkpad series will simply become accustomed to the new Chiclet design. After spending some time with the X230, we can say that the typing experience can be a little different for longtime ThinkPad users, but it is ultimately something that users must try first-hand before judging. After becoming habituated with the keyboard, you’ll find the very familiar but upgraded ThinkPad underneath that made the original X220 so popular in the first place.
...
What we'd like to see
Although the Precision Keyboard has its benefits, we can't help but feel that both the new Chiclet and old beveled styles have their own pros and cons. An option for  "Precision" or "Classic" would satisfy many fans. In general, we would like to see lower temperatures and perhaps an improved touchpad in future models.
...
不知道TP新鍵盤背光塗料能夠撐多久

之前經手一台VAIO
一年半的機子,使用者非常之頻繁使用鍵盤,很多都掉漆露背光...
整個很阿雜

手感可以習慣,但功能鍵被刪減才是個人認為的致命傷阿
  • 4
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?