• 2

在Dell 2005FPW和2001FP之間徘徊‧‧‧徵求意見中

最近從Dell Small Business上買了一個2005FPW,20.1' 的LCD顯示器。
但是看到網路上的討論後,發現自己也許犯了一個大錯誤,那就是:

2005FPW 雖然和2001FP一樣,都是20.1'。 但是,一個是1680*1050(寬螢幕,比例是16:10),而另一個是1600*1200(普通比例,4:3)。

2005FPW比較新,但是是寬螢幕。它的問題聽說比2001FP還少了很多。
2001FP比較舊,但是比較大,和PC遊戲應該也比較相容。但是相對的,它的問題也比較多,規格也沒有2005FPW好。

有很多人提起,2005FPW比較適合用來看影片;但是在下不常看影片,只看動畫。
也有很多人反駁,說現在也有很多遊戲支援寬螢幕,而且寬螢幕在未來是主流。

我在想的是,既然我要接一個電視盒玩PS2的話,哪一個顯示器會比較好?
我的電視盒支援640*480,800*600,1027*768,以及1280*1024。

2005FPW的規格:
Viewable Size: 20.1"
Height: Compressed: 15.3", Extended: 22.4"
Image Max H-View Angle: ±88°
Image Max V-View Angle: ±88°
Color Support: 16.7 Million
Device Type: Flat Panel LCD Monitor with Height Adjustable Stand
Dimensions (WxDxH) / Weight: 18.6" x 9" x 15.3" to 22.4" / 17.64 lbs
Image Aspect Ratio: 16:10
Image Brightness: 300 cd/m²
Image Contrast Ratio: 600:1
Max Resolution: 1680x1050 Pixels
Max Sync Rate (V x H): 75 Hz x 83 kHz
Port(s) Total ( Free ) / Connector Type: VGA / DVI-D / S-video / Composite / 4 x USB 2.0
Power Consumption Operational: 75 W (maximum), 55 W (typical)
Diagonal Size / Viewable Size: 20 / 20.1"

2001FP的規格:
Viewable Size: 20.1"
Depth: 9.67"
Height: With stand: 25" (fully extended in portrait mode), 18" (compressed/locked in landscape mode)
Weight: 18.72 lbs (with stand and head)
Width: 17.6"
Image Max H-View Angle: ± 88° (typical)
Image Max V-View Angle: ± 88° (typical)
Analog Video Format: Analog RGB
Digital Video Format: DVI-D TMDS
Dot Pitch: 0.255 mm pixel pitch
Image Brightness: 250 cd/m2 (typical)
Image Contrast Ratio: 400:1
Max Resolution: Up to 1600x1200 Pixels
Max Sync Rate (V x H): 76 Hz x 80 kHz
Port(s) Total ( Free ) / Connector Type: 1 x 15-pin D-sub, 1 x 24-pin Digital DVI-D, 1 x S-Video, 1 x Composite Video, 5 x USB (1 Upstream and 4 Downstream)
Power Consumption Operational: 90 W (max. with USB and Soundbar)
Video Input: Analog RGB, Digital DVI-D TMDS, S-Video, Composite Video


另外,到2/9為止,這2台顯示器都是同樣的價格喔。
$545美元,不含稅。

Dell 2005FPW
Dell 2001FP

可能會在拆封以前就拿去換一個2001FP吧‧‧‧不知道。

希望在01的各位提供意見。
2005-02-10 12:17 發佈
Hi I am also in the market for the LCD screen. Personally I will choose 2005FPW. the reason I choose 2005FPW over the 2001FP is because 2005FPW have better price advantage and wide screen lcd is going to be trim this year, which is also mean 4:6 screen's price is going to downward.2005FPW have lowest price in the wide 20inch market right now and its spec is not too bad ,too.
IMO if you want great PS game performance you will need a very very good TV BOX to do that rather then LCD and S Video is also a must.
Anyway I hope can see you review no matter which unit you purchase
I guess...
Personally I don't really have a big preference over normal aspect or wide screen. It's just that I am worried about screen stretching and stuff like that....things may look bad.
Many users online have reported extreme satisfaction regardless of the spec difference between the 2 units. However, since I am going to be using my new monitor for both work and play, I want it to be worthy of the money I pitched in.

Although 2001FP have many problems upon it's first release (screen door effect, etc...), Dell seemed to have addressed many of the issues with later revisions.
2005FPW also have problems too.....Again, Dell "fixed" them with newer revisions too.

Bottom line, I think both of these 2 monitors are a great choice no matter what I pick. It's just that 2001FP has more real estate with its traditional aspect ratios, while 2005FPW seems to have a better panel overall (since it's newer).

Who knows.....
I'll try and do a review when I get the stuff. Probably have to return them due to dead pixels or backlight leakage anyways...
我最近也在考慮20"的寬螢幕LCD,考慮Apple的20" 及 Dell 2005FPW
看來看企還是Dell的C/P值較高
不知那個大大可辦個團購?
不知道遠野兄的2005fpw是否到手了 , 使用狀況如何呢?
還是有意願頂讓.....^^
小弟很有誠意想要接手說......
我覺得2005FPW比較好
16:10的畫面其實我覺得很棒
打ps2也很適合
君不見$ony16:9 CRT在日本仍然是很搶手的
而且人的眼睛本來就適合看寬畫面的~~
總之
2005FPW比較適合哦!!!
買買買買..........
Comparing the area size, 2005FPW is nearly the same as 1905FP but 2001FP is 10% larger.

Considering 2100FP is 1 year old model, I think it is better to choose the newer model 2005FPW if the price is similar.

Or you may consider the latest model 24" 2405FPW if your budget allowed. In US it can have lowest price of US$860.



http://homepage.ntu.edu.tw/~r90123010/2005fpw.htm

2005FPW 可視區域比較小
2001FP 顏色跟gamma都比較準確漂亮
文學 葡萄酒 電影
先說我用的是2405fpw所以我只針對16:10來回應
16:10用久了會覺得方便很多....
可以兩個視窗並排
可以用的空間變的很大很方便
還有
要打ps2的話建議買有內建s端子的機型
差很多....比透過電視盒的好
我只能說我下一台螢幕一定還是寬螢幕的
p.s不過如果你要買2005fpw的話要看你用什麼管道
台灣沒有賣,kimo水貨好像賣兩萬多
維修也是個問題
先醬子

維修真的是一個問題,我自己今天買了一台2005FPW for only 400USD,便宜的沒話說。一堆朋友也想叫我幫他們帶,可是都因為維修的問題停步不前

晚點再來寫個測試報告吧。
  • 2
內文搜尋
X
評分
評分
複製連結
Mobile01提醒您
您目前瀏覽的是行動版網頁
是否切換到電腦版網頁呢?